Contributors

adam lapish

adam@lapish.net

matt edge

matt.edge1@btinternet.com

 

2008 Viewings

click on underlined films for review

Angus, Thongs & Perfect Snogging B (AL)

Australia D+ (AL)

The Baader Meinhof Complex C (AL)

The Bank Job C+ (AL)

Body of Lies A- (AL)

Burn After Reading C- (AL)

Changeling B (AL)

Che: Part One D+ (AL)

Cloverfield C+ (AL) A+ (ME)

The Curious Case of Benjamin Button D (AL)

The Dark Knight B- (AL) B+ (ME)

Death Race D+ (AL)

Defiance D (AL)

Donkey Punch F (AL)

Doubt B+(AL)

Eagle Eye D (AL)

Easy Virtue D (AL)

Elegy A (AL)

The Fall A- (AL)

The Forbidden Kingdom D- (AL)

Frost/Nixon A- (AL)

Frozen River B (AL)

Get Smart D (AL)

Ghost Town B+ (AL)

Gomorrah B (AL)

Hancock A- (AL) B+ (ME)

Happy-Go-Lucky B+(AL)

Hellboy II: The Golden Army A- (AL)

In Bruges D- (AL)

Indiana Jones and the Kingdom of the Crystal Skull B- (AL)

I've Loved You So Long A (AL)

Journey to the Centre of the Earth (3D) F (AL)

Lakeview Terrace B- (AL)

Let the Right One In B- (AL)

Mamma Mia! D (AL)

Man on Wire B+(AL)

Married Life B- (AL)

Milk B (AL)

Nick & Norah's Infinite Playlist C- (AL)

The Orphanage B- (ME)

Pineapple Express D- (AL)

Pride and Glory D (AL)

OSS117: Cairo - Nest of Spies D+ (AL)

Quantum of Solace C+ (AL)

Quarantine B- (AL)

Rambo D+ (AL)

The Reader D+ (AL)

[Rec] A (AL) A+ (ME)

Redbelt C (AL)

Revolutionary Road A (AL)

Role Models B (AL)

Sex and the City B+ (AL)

Shine a Light A (AL)

Slumdog Millionaire B+ (AL)

Taken C+ (AL)

Teeth B+ (AL)

Tropic Thunder B (AL)

Twilight B+ (AL)

Valkyrie C- (AL)

Vicky Cristina Barcelona A+ (AL)

The Visitor A- (AL)

The Wackness B- (AL)

Wall*E B+ (AL)

Wanted C+ (AL)

Wendy and Lucy C+ (AL)

What Happened in Vegas B- (ME)

The Wrestler A (AL)

 

Film Links

BoxOfficeMojo

IMDb

Hollywood-Elsewhere

TheHotBlog

InContention

Metacritic

Rottentomatoes

 

 

Eagle Eye

USA, 2008

Director:

DJ Caruso

Starring:

Shia Leboeuf
Michaelle Monaghan
Billy Bob Thornton
Michael Chiklis
Rosario Dawson

Matt: -

Adam: D

   

 

Myfilmvault watches the crap so you don't have to!

Eagle Eye isn't worth much discussion other than to point out that it's the new DJ Caruso/Shia Leboeuf effort. Caruso also directed Leboeuf in last year's far better Disturbia which, as reported here, was hit by a lawsuit from the rights holders to Rear Window for making what they claim was an unauthorised remake of Hitchcock's classic - which it unarguably was, even if it was quite enjoyable and a moderate success. Caruso and his screenwriting team have been a little more savvy this time, ripping off more than one Hitchcock film and coming up with their own plot - of sorts - to avoid any repeat litigation.

Eagle Eye bears more than a passing resemblance to North by Northwest, although this is a film very much with its own storyline (albeit an incredibly preposterous one.) Trouble is Leboeuf is no Cary Grant, Michelle Monaghan isn't Eva Marie Saint, Caruso isn't Hitchcock and Eagle Eye isn't very good. The problems, of varying importance, include Leboeuf's ridiculous facial hair, no chemistry at all between the two leads, Monaghan proving herself totally incapable of convincing in any given scene and a plot that holds up to no scrutiny at all. Worst of all, it's just not in the least bit interesting to a chase movie where the bad guy is a (spoiler in white) computer.

This is not worth the price of admission, so save your hard earned money. Heck, this isn't even worth the price of a cheap pirated knock off.

AL